How the Stars Fell
By THE NEW YORK TIMES
The restaurants that Sam Sifton reviewed in his tenure as The Times’s critic, broken down by rating. A handful — M. Wells, Mia Dona, Choptank, Motorino Williamsburg and Xiao Ye — have closed. His final review as the critic, on Per Se, appears this week.
Four Stars
Per Se, Del Posto
Three Stars
Craft, Masa, Gotham Bar and Grill, Chef’s Table at Brooklyn Fare, Veritas, Ai Fiori, Colicchio & Sons, La Grenouille, Marea
Two Stars
Tertulia, Roberta’s, Boulud Sud, the Leopard at Des Artistes, Brushstroke, The Dutch, M. Wells, Junoon, Red Rooster Harlem, the John Dory Oyster Bar, Millesime, Kin Shop, Riverpark, Lincoln Ristorante, Marc Forgione, Vandaag, Il Matto, Tamarind Tribeca, Aquavit, Má Pêche, Annisa, Torrisi Italian Specialties, Prime Meats, the Mark Restaurant by Jean-Georges, Recette, Strip House, Novitá, Maialino, Casa Lever, A Voce Columbus, Oceana, Ciano, SHO Shaun Hergatt, ABC Kitchen, DBGB Kitchen and Bar
One Star
Coppelia, St. Anselm, 456 Shanghai Cuisine, Hospoda, Desmond’s, Anella, Tenpenny, Colonie, Danji, Empellón, Palm, Palm Too, Graffit, Niko, Tulsi, Bar Basque, Hunan Kitchen of Grand Sichuan, The Fat Radish, Lyon, Peels, the Lambs Club, Nuela, Fornino Park Slope, Toloache, the Lion, Balaboosta, Takashi, Fatty ’Cue, Pulino’s Bar & Pizzeria, Faustina, Tanoreen, Motorino, the Breslin, Purple Yam, Tanuki Tavern, Madangsui, SD26, Aureole, Le Relais de Venise L’entrecôte, Imperial Palace, Chin Chin, La Petite Maison, the National Bar and Dining Rooms, the Hurricane Club, Wall & Water, Osteria Morini
Satisfactory
Miss Lily’s Favourite Cakes, Mia Dona, Choptank, Ed’s Chowder House
Fair
Imperial No. Nine, Plein Sud, Fishtag, Lavo, Xiao Ye, Kenmare, Nello, Le Caprice
